If you’ve ever reached for your favorite hair gel only to find it’s empty, you’re not alone. Maybe you’re also tired of the crunch, flakes, or dryness that come with regular gel. The good news? There are plenty of hair gel substitutes that give you style, hold, and shine—without damaging your hair. In this guide, we’ll explore the best natural and DIY alternatives, how to make them at home, and which works best for your hair type.
Why Look for a Hair Gel Substitute?
Hair gel is popular for its strong hold and styling flexibility. Yet many commercial gels contain alcohols, parabens, and artificial fragrances that strip away natural oils. Over time, this leads to brittle strands and scalp irritation.
Here are a few common reasons people switch to substitutes:
- Healthier Ingredients: Natural substitutes use nourishing oils, seeds, and plant extracts.
- Better Texture: They hold styles without making your hair feel stiff.
- Eco-Friendly Choice: Many substitutes are biodegradable and chemical-free.
- Budget Benefits: DIY recipes cost pennies compared to salon products.
A good hair gel substitute gives you control, style, and moisture—minus the damage.
Top Natural Hair Gel Substitutes
These natural alternatives are proven favorites for both men and women. They offer hold, flexibility, and a touch of nourishment that regular gels can’t match.
1. Aloe Vera Gel – Nature’s Hair Styler
Aloe vera is a classic hair gel substitute thanks to its smooth texture and soothing properties. It hydrates dry strands while taming frizz. Rich in vitamins A, C, and E, it strengthens hair cuticles and boosts shine.
How to Use:
- Apply a small amount to damp hair.
- Comb through for even distribution.
- Let it air dry for a soft, natural finish.
Pro Tip: Mix with a drop of argan or lavender oil for extra moisture and fragrance.
2. Flaxseed Gel – The DIY Champion
Flaxseed gel has become a cult favorite in the natural hair community. It’s easy to make, rich in Omega-3 fatty acids, and provides light-to-medium hold.
Recipe:
- Boil ¼ cup of flaxseeds in 2 cups of water.
- Stir until it forms a gel-like consistency.
- Strain and store in a glass jar (keep refrigerated).
Benefits:
- Defines curls without stiffness.
- Adds volume and moisture.
- Free from chemicals or artificial agents.
Case Study: Many curly-haired users report stronger, shinier curls after switching from commercial gel to homemade flaxseed gel for just three weeks.
3. Coconut Oil – The Shine Enhancer
Coconut oil isn’t just for cooking. It’s one of the best natural styling agents for taming frizz and adding a glossy finish. It’s particularly useful for people with thick or coarse hair.
How to Use:
- Warm a pea-sized amount in your palms.
- Run fingers through dry or damp hair.
- Style as usual.
Quick Facts:
- Best for humid weather.
- Use sparingly—too much can make hair greasy.
- Offers natural protection against UV rays.
4. Shea Butter – The Curl Definer
Shea butter works like a dream for curly, coily, and textured hair. Its rich, creamy texture provides hold and hydration. It also seals in moisture, preventing dryness and breakage.
Usage Tips:
- Melt a small amount and mix with aloe vera gel.
- Apply it before twist-outs, braids, or blow-drying.
- Store in a cool, dry place.
Fun Fact: Shea butter has been used in Africa for centuries to protect hair and skin from extreme heat.
5. Beeswax – The Strong-Hold Substitute
If you need lasting hold for slicked-back styles or edges, beeswax is a powerful choice. It creates a barrier that locks in moisture while keeping hair in place all day.
How to Apply:
- Soften beeswax by heating it slightly.
- Blend with coconut oil for easier use.
- Apply lightly to style and shape.
Best For:
- Short hairstyles.
- Beards and mustaches.
- Edge control for braids or locs.
DIY Hair Gel Substitutes You Can Make at Home
Homemade substitutes not only save money but also give you full control over what touches your scalp. Let’s explore a few popular recipes.
Flaxseed Gel Recipe
Here’s a detailed breakdown of this popular DIY favorite:
| Ingredient | Purpose | Effect on Hair |
| Flaxseeds | Base | Natural, flexible hold |
| Vitamin E oil | Preservative | Adds shine, extends shelf life |
| Aloe Vera | Moisturizer | Soft, smooth texture |
Storage Tip: Keep it in the fridge and use within 7 days.
Cornstarch Gel
This simple, budget-friendly gel is perfect when you’re short on supplies.
Ingredients:
- 1 cup water
- 1 tablespoon cornstarch
- 1 teaspoon coconut oil
Directions:
- Mix water and cornstarch in a saucepan.
- Heat until thickened.
- Remove from heat, stir in coconut oil, and cool.
It gives a light, flexible hold that works well for fine or straight hair.
Chia Seed Gel
Chia seeds aren’t just for smoothies—they’re also a hidden gem for hair.
How to Make:
- Soak 2 tablespoons of chia seeds in a cup of water overnight.
- Strain the next morning and apply to damp hair.
This gel adds moisture, controls frizz, and promotes hair growth thanks to its Omega-3 and protein content.
Hair Gel Substitutes for Different Hair Types
Choosing the right substitute depends on your hair texture, length, and desired finish.
Fors Curly Hair
- Top Picks: Aloe Vera, Flaxseed Gel, Shea Butter.
- Why: They define curls and prevent dryness.
- Tip: Use a diffuser when drying to enhance natural curl patterns.
For Straight Hair
- Top Picks: Cornstarch Gel, Aloe Vera.
- Why: Lightweight formulas won’t weigh hair down.
- Tip: Apply to damp roots for volume.
For Thick or Coarse Hair
- Top Picks: Beeswax, Coconut Oil, Shea Butter.
- Why: These provide stronger hold and lock in hydration.
- Tip: Use a comb to evenly distribute thicker products.
Store-Bought Hair Gel Alternatives Worth Trying
If DIY isn’t your thing, these store-bought options deliver professional results with natural ingredients.
| Brand | Main Ingredient | Hold Level | Best For |
| EcoStyler Olive Oil Gel | Olive Oil | Medium | Curly Hair |
| Andalou Styling Gel | Aloe Vera | Light | Fine Hair |
| SheaMoisture Curl Enhancing Smoothie | Shea Butter | Strong | Coarse Hair |
| Maui Moisture Curl Quench Gel | Coconut Oil | Medium | Wavy Hair |
| Giovanni LA Hold Styling Gel | Natural Extracts | Strong | All Hair Types |
These gels bridge the gap between traditional and natural styling products, offering control without the harsh chemicals.
How to Choose the Right Hair Gel Substitute
To find your perfect match, consider:
- Hair Texture: Fine hair benefits from lighter formulas, while thick hair needs richer ones.
- Climate: In humid conditions, avoid heavy oils that may melt or attract dirt.
- Desired Hold: Decide whether you want flexible movement or a firm grip.
Quick Flowchart Example:
→ Want light hold and shine? Try Aloe Vera Gel.
→ Need curl definition and hydration? Use Flaxseed Gel.
→ Looking for long-lasting hold? Beeswax is your best bet.
Common Mistakes When Using Hair Gel Substitutes
Even natural products can backfire if misused. Here’s what to avoid:
- Excessive use: Applying an excessive amount of the product can result in hair looking oily or weighed down.
- Poor Storage: Homemade gels without preservatives spoil quickly.
- Mixing Errors: Combining incompatible ingredients may lead to flakes or clumps.
Pro Tip: Always test new mixtures on a small section of hair first.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use Vaseline as a substitute?
Technically yes, but it’s not ideal. Vaseline offers hold, but it’s petroleum-based, making it hard to wash out and prone to buildup.
Which alternative lasts the longest?
Beeswax and Shea Butter last the longest due to their dense, waxy textures. However, they may require stronger shampoos for removal.
Are substitutes safe for colored or treated hair?
Yes. In fact, many natural substitutes like aloe vera and flaxseed are gentler and protect color-treated strands better than alcohol-based gels.
Final Thoughts: Embrace Natural Styling
Switching to a natural hair gel substitute doesn’t mean sacrificing style. Whether you prefer a light, bouncy look or a firm, sleek finish, there’s an alternative that fits your needs. Experiment with DIY recipes or eco-friendly brands to discover what your hair loves most.
Quote to Remember:
“Having healthy hair does not mean achieving perfection; it revolves around regular care and maintenance.”
By moving away from harsh gels, you’re not just improving your style—you’re investing in your hair’s long-term health and natural beauty. Try one of these options today, and let your hair shine its way—naturally.
Leave a Reply